Out of step, then suddenly in step

Three hundred metronomes, every one set to a slightly different tempo, each able to feel the beat of all the others a little. Turn up how strongly they feel it. For a long way nothing happens at all. Then, past one particular strength, they lock.

The rules, all of them. Each metronome has its own natural tempo; the tempos are spread around a common average. Each is nudged towards the average beat of the whole group, by an amount set by the slider. Nobody conducts. The red arrow joins the middle of the circle to the centre of all the dots: its length is how far in step they are.

This is Yoshiki Kuramoto's model, and for a very large group it can be solved exactly. Below a critical nudge (here 1.0: twice the spread of the tempos) the group stays scattered. Above it the group partly locks, to a degree √(1 − critical ÷ nudge), which the experiments confirm with 4,000 metronomes. The same mathematics has been used to explain fireflies flashing together, audiences clapping in time, and the sideways sway of London's Millennium Bridge on its opening day in 2000. What it leaves out: real metronomes on a real board, real feet on a real bridge. Three hundred is few enough that chance alone keeps the arrow from ever reaching zero.