Better in every department, worse overall
In the autumn of 1973 the University of California, Berkeley admitted 44% of the men who applied to its six largest graduate departments and 30% of the women. Then somebody looked at the departments one at a time.
What this is. The table published by Peter Bickel, Eugene Hammel and William O'Connell in Science in 1975: applicants and admissions by sex for the six largest departments (labelled A to F in the paper), 4,526 applicants in all. Every figure on the page is a count from that table or a share of two counts.
In four of the six departments women were admitted at a higher rate than men, and in the other two the gap is small. The overall figure points the other way because of where people applied: half the men applied to departments A and B, which admitted nearly two thirds of everyone, while more than nine women in ten applied to C to F, which admitted about a third or fewer. The slider moves the women's applications to where the men's went, leaving each department's own admission rate for women untouched; their overall rate rises from 30% to 52%. This is Simpson's paradox: a pattern in every group can reverse when the groups are added together. The table cannot say why men and women applied to different departments, and the university's other departments are not in it.